Tata Punch EV vs MG Comet EV
- Like
- Comment
- Share
Overview
| Specs Score | 48 / 100 Better Specs | 27 / 100 |
General
| Country of Origin | India | |
| Model | Punch EV | Comet EV |
| Type | Compact SUV | Micro Car |
| Colors | Apple Green and Starry Black, Candy White and Starry Black, Aurora Silver, Candy White, Starry Black | |
| Warranty Details | 3 years, Upto 1.25 Lakh Kms | 3 years, Upto 1 Lakh Kms |
Engine and Transmission Details
| Motor Type | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor |
| Motor Power | 95 kW | 30.89 kW |
| Maximum Power | 127.4 bhp | 42 bhp |
| Maximum Torque | 154 Nm | 110 Nm |
| Transmission Type | Automatic (Electric) | Automatic (Electric) |
| Mild Hybrid | No | |
| Gear Box | 1 Speed Automatic (Electric) Gear Box |
Battery Details
| Battery | 40 kWh | 17.3 kWh, Li-ion |
| Charging Port | CCS 2 | CCS 2 |
| Charging Power | 3.3 kW (AC), 65 kW (DC) | 3.3 kW (AC) |
| Charging Time | 14.8 hours (AC) at Home, 5.3 hours (AC), 30 min (DC) | 7 hours (AC) |
| Included Charger | 3.3 kW AC Wall Box | |
| Regenerative Braking | Yes, 4 Levels | Yes |
| Motor / Battery IP Rating | IP67 | IP67 |
| Thermal Management System | Liquid Cooled System | |
| Battery Features | i-6-in-1 box | |
| Battery Warranty | 8 years, Upto 1.6 Lakh Kms | 8 years, Upto 1.2 Lakh Kms |
Performance Details
| Top Speed | 101 km/h | |
| Acceleration Details | 0-100 kmph in 9 sec | |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Electric |
| Range | Up to ~335 - 355 km | Up to 230 km |
| Emission Norm Compliance | Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) | Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) |
Suspension and Handling Details
| Front Suspension | Independent, Lower Wishbone, McPherson Strut with Coil Spring | McPherson Strut |
| Rear Suspension | Semi-independent Twist Beam With Coil Spring And Shock Absorber | Multi-Link Coil Suspension |
| Steering Type | Electric | Electric |
| Adjustable Steering | Yes | Yes, Tilt |
| Brake Type | Disc (Front), Drum (Rear) | Disc (Front), Disc (Rear) |
| Turning Radius | 5 m | 4.2 m |
Body Design Details
| Kerb Weight | 815 kg | |
| Length | 3880 mm | 2974 mm |
| Width | 1742 mm | 1505 mm |
| Height | 1622 mm | 1640 mm |
| Ground Clearance (Unladen) | 195 mm | |
| Wheel Base | 2445 mm | 2010 mm |
| Tyre Type | Tubeless | Tubeless, Radial |
| Tyre Size | 195/60 R16 | 145/70 R12 |
| Number Of Doors | 5 | 2 |
| Seating Capacity | 5 Seater | 4 Seater |
| Boot Space | 366 L |
Comfort and Convenience Details
| Engine Start/Stop Button | Yes | Yes |
| Automatic Climate Control | Yes | No |
| Air Purifier | Yes | |
| Power Windows Front | Yes | Yes |
| Power Windows Rear | Yes | |
| One Touch Power Windows | Driver Only, Auto Up | |
| Remote Boot Opener | Yes | |
| Cruise Control | Yes | |
| Inbuilt Navigation System | Yes | Yes |
| Keyless Entry | Yes | Yes, with Intelligent Key |
| Drive Modes | City, Sport, Eco | |
| Glove Box Cooling | Yes | |
| Voice Control | Yes | Yes |
| Voice Control Features | Multiple Voice Assistants (“Hey Tata”, Alexa, Siri, Google Assistant) | Voice Commands For Car Functions, Ac On/off, Radio, Remaining Mileage, Etc. |
| Central Console Armrest | Yes, with Storage | |
| Power Outlet 12V | Front | |
| USB Charging Port Front | Yes, USB Type ‑ A+C Fast Charging Port (65W) | Yes, x2, Fast Charging |
| USB Charging Port Rear | Yes, USB Type - C Fast Charging Port (15W) | Yes, x1, Fast Charging |
| Foldable Rear Seat | Yes, 50:50 Foldable Seat | |
| Vanity Mirror | Passenger Side | Driver & Passenger Side |
| Passenger Accessories | Rear Seat Headrest, Rear Seat Centre Arm Rest | Cabin Light Front, Rear Reading Lamp, Rear Seat Headrest |
| Driver Rear View Monitor (DRVM) | Yes | |
| Adjustable Headrest | Front, Rear | |
| Bottle Holder | Front, Rear | Front, 0.5L |
| Steering Features | 3-Spoke, Paddle Shifters | Leather Wrapped, 3-Spoke |
| Extra Features | One-touch Slide And Recline Passenger Seat For 2nd Row Entry, Creep Mode, Front Co-Driver Grab Handle, Digital Key with sharing function |
Styling Features
| ORVM Color | Body Colored | Body Colored |
| Bumper Color | Body Colored | Body Colored |
| Flush Door Handles | No | |
| Door Handle Color | Body Colored | Chrome |
| Interior Door Handle Finish | Chrome | |
| Exterior Style | Dual Tone | Dual Tone |
| Dashboard Style | Dual Tone, Space Grey |
Features
| Steering Mounted Controls | Audio, MID, Bluetooth, Phone | Audio |
| Alloy Wheels | Yes | No |
Safety Features
| Anti Lock Braking System (ABS) | Yes | Yes |
| Electronic Brake force Distribution (EBD) | Yes | Yes |
| Speed-Sense Auto Door Lock | Yes | |
| Impact-Sense Auto Door Unlock | Yes | Yes |
| Seat Belt Warning | Yes | |
| Rear Seat Belt Warning | Yes | |
| ISOFIX Child Seat Mount | Yes | Yes |
| Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS) | Yes | Yes, Indirect |
| IRVM Type | Auto Dimming | Manual Day & Night |
| Parking Sensors | Rear | Rear |
| Number Of Airbags | 6 | 2 |
| Airbags | Driver, Passenger, Side, Curtain | Driver, Passenger |
| Seat Belts | Rear Seat Belts | Rear Seat Belts, Rear Middle Seat Belt |
| Pretensioners And Force Limiter Seatbelt | Front, Driver & Co-driver Seat Belt With Load Limiter | |
| Vehicle Control | Electronic Stability Program (ESP), Hill Descent Control, Hill Start Assist | Electronic Stability Program (ESP), Hill Start Assist |
| Electric Parking Brake (EPB) | Yes, with Auto Hold | Yes |
| Door Lock | Central Locking | Central Locking, Child Safety Locks |
| Headlamps | LED Headlamps, Automatic Headlamps, Follow Me Home Headlamps | LED Headlamps, Follow Me Home Headlamps |
| Daytime Running Lights (DRLs) | Yes, LED DRLs | Yes, LED DRLs |
| High Beam Assist | Yes | |
| Reverse Camera | Yes | Yes |
| 360° View Camera | Yes | |
| Advanced Safety Features | Manual Parking Brake, 3-point Seat Belts For All Passengers | |
| Extra Features | IP67 Rated Battery |
Advanced Driver Assistance System (ADAS) Features
| Blind Spot Monitor | Yes |
Interior Features
| Air Conditioner | Yes | Yes |
| Heater | Yes | Yes |
| Instrument Cluster | 10.25 inches, Digital | Digital |
| Tachometer | Yes | Yes |
| Digital Odometer | Yes | Yes |
| Electronic Multi Trip Meter | Yes | |
| Glove Compartment | Yes, with Cooling | Yes |
| Adjustable Seats | Manual Adjustable Seats, Manual Height Adjustable Driving Seat | |
| Seats Features | Ventilated Front Seats | |
| Seat Upholstery | Leatherette | Fabric |
| Extra Features | Jeweled Control Knob | Space Grey Interiors, PVC Layering On Door Trim |
Exterior Features
| Adjustable Headlights | Yes | |
| Front Fog Lights | Yes, LED | |
| Rear Fog Lights | Yes, LED | |
| Tail Lights | LED, Digital Infinity Glow End-to-End Tail Lamp | LED, Modern Parallel Steps |
| Cornering Foglamps | Yes | |
| Wheel Design | Alloy, Diamond Cut Alloy Wheels | Steel With Covers |
| Lighting | Extended Horizon Front & Rear Connecting Lights | |
| Defoggers | Front Window Defogger, Rear Window Defogger | Front Window Defogger |
| Rain Sensing Wiper | Yes | |
| Rear Window Wiper | Yes, with Washer | |
| Electric Folding ORVM | Yes, with Auto Fold | Yes |
| Outside Rear View Mirror (ORVM) | ORVM Turn Indicators, Electrically Adjustable ORVM | ORVM Turn Indicators, Electrically Adjustable ORVM |
| Roof Features | Roof Rail | |
| Sunroof | Yes, Voice‑assisted Electric | |
| Extra Features | Illuminated MG Logo, Aero Wiper, Body Colored Side Garnish |
Connectivity
| Wifi | Yes | |
| Bluetooth | Yes | |
| USB Input Port | Yes | Yes |
| Auxiliary Input Port | Yes | |
| Android Auto | Yes, Wireless | Yes, Wireless |
| Apple Carplay | Yes, Wireless | Yes, Wireless |
| Wireless Charging | Yes | |
| Other Connectivity Features | Arcade.ev 2.0 App Suite |
Connected Car Technology
| Connected Car Tech | Yes, iRA.ev | Yes, i-Smart |
| Geofence | Yes | Yes |
| Remote Vehicle Tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Remote Vehicle Status | Yes | Yes |
| Remote AC Start | Yes | Yes |
| App To Car Connectivity | Yes | Yes |
| Door Lock Via APP | Yes | Yes |
| Door Unlock Via APP | Yes | Yes |
| Emergency SOS Alert | Yes | |
| Other Connected Car Features | Smartwatch Connectivity, Alexa Car to Home | i-SMART with 55+ Connectd Car Features, Chit Chat Voice Interaction, 30+ Hinglish Voice Commands, Voice Commands (Weather, Cricket, Calculator, Clock, Date/day, Horoscope, Dictionary, News & Knowledge), Widget Customisation Of Homescreen With Multiple Pages, Customisable Lock Screen Wallpaper, Theme Store To Download Themes, Brightness Sync Function (For Infotainment And Cluster), Birthday Wish On Headunit, Charging Details On Infotainment, Maximum Speed Setting On Infotainment (From 30 to 80 km/h), Online Music App, Digital Key With Key Sharing Function, In Car Remote Control In i-smart APP (Audio, Ac On/off), Live Location Sharing & Tracking, Approach Unlock Function, Find My Car, Vehicle Start Alarm, Vehicle Overspeed Alert With Customisable Speed Limit, Smart Drive Information, Charging Station Search, 100% Charging Notification On i-SMART App, Critical Tyre Pressure Voice Alert, Low Battery Alert At Ignition On (For Both 12V And EV Battery), E-Call (For Safety), I-Call (For Convenience), Over The Air (OTA) Updates, Preloaded Greeting Message On Entry, Departure "Good Bye" Message On Exit, Ecotree - CO2 Saved Data On Infotainment And i-SMART App |
Infotainment Features
| Touch Screen | Yes | Yes |
| Display Size | 10.25 inches | 10.25 inches |
| Front Speakers | Yes | Yes |
| Rear Speakers | Yes | |
| Speakers Count | 4 | 2 |
| Media Player | Radio | Radio |
Discuss
Be the first to leave a comment.
